Handcrafted Artisan Cheese Made Fresh in Ohio

Name: Blue Jacket Dairy
Address: 1434 County Road 11, Bellefontaine, OH, 43311-9745, US
Telephone: 937-292-7327

We create great-tasting, small-batch cheeses using local Ohio milk. From fresh, squeaky curds to aged cheddar-style favorites, every batch is crafted by hand for simple, delicious flavor. Explore our cheeses and taste the difference of truly local artisan creamery.

SHOP CHEESE

Shipping & Local Pickup Available

Holiday Ordering & Pickup

Cheese gift baskets and cheese trays are available by pre-order with 24 hours notice.

Pickup options

• In-store pickup in Bellefontaine
• Worthington Farmers Market pickup, Saturday, December 20

Shipping

• Regional UPS shipping to surrounding states
• Order by December 21

Christmas Week Hours

• Monday and Tuesday, December 22 and 23: 9 am to 5 pm
• Christmas Eve: 9 am to noon

Shop Cheese

Great tasting cheese made at the highest point in Ohio

Cheese Curds

Experience our signature fresh cheese curds—squeaky, creamy, and made daily with local Ohio milk. From classic Plain to bold flavors, they’re a customer favorite for snacking, recipes, and party trays.

Quark

Our handcrafted Quark cheeses are smooth, creamy, and endlessly versatile. Spread them on toast, pair with fruit, or use in your favorite recipes. Choose from classic, sweet, or savory flavors—all made with simple ingredients.

Grenta Grillin'

Enjoy our halloumi-style Gretna Grillin’ cheese—perfect for frying, grilling, or adding to salads and sandwiches. With a buttery flavor and beautiful golden crust, it’s a staple for cooks who love versatile artisan cheese.

Aged Cheese

Taste our small-batch cheddar-style cheeses, carefully aged for rich flavor and a smooth, satisfying finish. These make excellent additions to charcuterie boards and thoughtful gifts.

Wholesale Pricing

For Chefs and Restaurants: Blue Jacket Dairy proudly partners with chefs and restaurants across Ohio, offering farm-fresh, artisan cheeses crafted in small batches. Whether you’re planning a seasonal menu or elevating your farm-to-table offerings, our locally sourced cheese makes the difference.
👉 Learn more about our artisan cheeses for chefs.

Are you a retailer looking to add local cheese to your store? Look no further! Our Ohio cheese is the perfect addition to your selection. Contact us today to learn more about how we can work together.